****************************************************
Magnolia Political Report #48
October 22, 2003
****************************************************
Musgrove’s
Closet
Subscribers to the American Family Association’s e-mail list received
an interesting e-mail this week from Rev. Don Wildmon, the Founder and
Chairman of the group. The e-mail detailed information about Fred Zeytoonjian,
the Office Director for Governor Ronnie Musgrove’s Office in Washington,
D.C.
Rev. Wildmon’s message stated, “The values of the person filling
the top non-elective office in our nation’s capitol is of concern
to me, as I know it is to you… What are the values Mr. Zeytoonjian
holds? Mr. Zeytoonjian signed the document called the Affirmation of Family
Diversity, part of Alternatives to Marriage Project. Among other issues
Affirmation of Family Diversity promotes is the belief that "same-sex
couples should be able to choose marriage. . ." and that "ignoring
the needs of gay, lesbian, bisexual and transgender people are not positive
approaches for supporting families." I seriously doubt that many
Mississippians share Mr. Zeytoonjianís views that the marriage
of two women or two men, or indeed any other combination, should be treated
as being perfectly normal and legal and morally acceptable.
“On June 26, after the Supreme Court ruled sodomy legal, here is
what the Affirmation of Family Diversity group had to say: "A day
for dancing in the streets! The Supreme Court’s decision that sodomy
laws are unconstitutional means that unmarried couples (same-sex and different-sex)
who have private, consensual sex are no longer criminals in the 13 states
where these laws were still on the books. The decision could put an end
to some kinds of discrimination on the basis of marital status and sexual
orientation." I doubt if there were many Mississippians dancing in
the streets because of the legalization of sodomy.”
Rev. Wildmon also made note of the fact that many of the websites detailing
Mr. Zeytoonjian’s views and activities have mysteriously disappeared
from the Internet. “Mr. Zeytoonjian is an activist who had his own
website pushing his agenda (before removing it after it became public
knowledge). His company produced a film (Wedding Advice: Speak Now or
Forever Hold Your Peace-Exploring Contemporary American Ambivalence about
Marriage) which says that marriage is oppressive to single people. He
and his friend have cohabited for 18 years, and he still feels "ambivalent"
about marriage. I am disappointed that instead of publicly addressing
this situation, someone simply had Mr. Zeytoonjianís web site removed.
I can only guess that someone just wanted to destroy the evidence.”
Sign-Gate
The
war of words between candidates for Attorney General heated up this week
when the Newton campaign caught Hood campaign manager Morgan Shands pulling-up
Newton campaign signs. Shands was caught red handed pulling up the signs
when he was video taped trashing Newton signs supposedly in front of the
Hood campaign headquarters. However, Shands claims that he was set up
by the Newton campaign when he returned from dinner to find a damaged
Hood 4x8 and Newton yard signs in front of their North street headquarters.
Click here to watch
Ad Wars
Click to watch
Barbour/
Musgrove – Cochran spot; Senator Thad Cochran doesn’t
usually involve himself in political campaigns other than his own. But
he made an exception for his good friend Haley Barbour. In one of the
more effective spots of the campaign season, a Barbour for Governor ad
featuring Cochran is currently running state-wide. Cochran is one of the
most revered figures in Mississippi public life, having received a larger
percentage of his state’s vote than any other United States Senator.
Many endorsements don’t carry much weight, but Cochran appears to
be conquering some turf for Barbour.
In
the spot Cochran lauds his “good friend” Haley Barbour, calling
him a Mississippi success story. He even goes so far as to take Governor
Musgrove to task (though not by name) for “false misleading attacks”
on Barbour.
Ronnie
Musgrove has stuck to constant themes in his last several spots. Musgrove
has sought to portray Barbour as a Washington lobbyist and has tried to
hang NAFTA around his neck. Musgrove may have pushed it too far by accusing
Barbour of “poisoning children” through his work lobbying
on behalf of Tobacco Companies during negotiations on the national tobacco
settlement.
Tuck
– Lt. Gov. Amy Tuck is up with an ad making hay off of Barbara Blackmon’s
colossal blunder on the touchy subject of abortion. Several weeks ago,
after Tuck was endorsed by two Right to Life groups, Blackmon challenged
Tuck to sign an affidavit swearing she has never had an abortion. Newspapers
around the state pounced on Blackmon for the comments, which they considered
out of bounds.
Tuck’s
ad begins with negative quotes about Blackmon from editorials from four
state newspapers. The second part of the ad highlights some less than
popular votes Blackmon made in the State Senate. It finishes by concluding
that Barbara Blackmon had a “radical” record in the Senate.
Blackmon
– A week before Tuck hit the airwaves with her ad on her opponent,
Blackmon was up with a spot blaming Mississippi’s poor economic
performance the past few years of Tuck. The first part of the spot featured
a clip from Tuck’s first commercial – the one with the red
50’s era pick-up pulling a car out of the mud. Tuck’s spot
was making the point that the state’s economy is “stuck in
the mud” and that stopping lawsuit abuse is the way to get it going.
Blackmon used the footage to say Tuck is the problem.
Blackmon
was taken to task by WAPT-TV in Jackson for a later claim in the ad. According
to Blackmon’s commercial, she had been an insider on the deal that
landed Nissan in Canton. WAPT researched the claim and concluded it is
false.
Trends
Governor
The
race for Governor looks like it will come down to the wire. Neither candidate
has gotten much separation, though Barbour has a slight lead in most polls
seen by the Magnolia Report.
Governor
Ronnie Musgrove apparently wavered on even getting into the race in the
first place. It was widely reported at the time that he was heavily lobbying
for the presidency of Delta State University in the days before the March
1st qualifying deadline. When Musgrove didn’t get the job, he threw
his hat into the ring for re-election.
After
a slow start with fundraising, Musgrove has become more and more aggressive
on the campaign trail. According to campaign finance reports, Musgrove
should have enough money to keep up with rival Barbour. Musgrove has tirelessly
worked to define Barbour as an outsider and he hammers Barbour constantly
on ties he made during his successful career as a lobbyist.
Barbour
ran months of positive television prior to Musgrove hitting the airwaves
in September. Out of the gate, Musgrove began taking swings at Barbour.
Press accounts tend to hold both candidates responsible for the negative
tone of the campaign – but it is interesting to note which candidate
a negative tenor benefits the most.
To
a degree, Barbour – as any challenger facing an incumbent –
must convince voters they made a mistake in electing Musgrove in 1999.
However, Musgrove didn’t win a majority in 1999 and since then he’s
supported a disastrous referendum on the state flag and has presided over
a huge fiscal downturn in the state.
To
win, Barbour needs a heavy turn-out among voters most disaffected with
Musgrove’s leadership as governor – mostly white voters from
both suburban and rural parts of the state. Musgrove on the other hand
must get out his Democrat base and pick-off enough swing voters to get
at least a plurality of the vote.
Musgrove
is aiming at primarily rural white men worried about the jobs in his effort
to secure the swing voters needed for victory. This is why he works NAFTA
into almost every comment he makes. He’s working his traditional
Democrat base in ways that don’t always show up on the radar screen
– like get-out-the-vote rallies and other GOTV activities.
The
other key component in Musgrove’s strategy appears to by denying
Barbour the votes he needs form suburban and rural white to win. Musgrove
doesn’t necessarily have to get those voters to cast their ballots
for him. Those voters not showing up at the polls for Barbour would be
almost as good for Musgrove.
In
that regard, the perceived negative tone of the campaign may benefit Musgrove
the most. In study after study, negative campaigns depress voter turnout,
and they depress turnout the most among the very voters Barbour needs
to win.
Lt.
Governor
The
past three weeks haven’t been good ones for Democratic nominee Barbara
Blackmon. Lt. Gov. Amy Tuck benefited from a September visit by President
George W. Bush and from a few weeks of running TV spots in the clear (Blackmon
wasn’t up at the same time). Then Blackmon made her disastrous comments
challenging Tuck to sign an affidavit swearing she’d never had an
abortion. The trifecta for Tuck left her in an enviable position. The
race looks like hers to win.
Attorney
General
Democratic
nominee Jim Hood and Republican nominee Scott Newton are slugging it out
on television. Both are struggling to build name ID while hanging significant
negatives on his opponent. Newton has to cut into the base of support
Hood built while he was a district attorney in North Mississippi.
Treasurer
Democrat
Gary Anderson and Republican Tate Reeves are both struggling to build
name ID in a down-ballot race that is hard to finance. Reeves built some
name ID with primary ads in Central and South Mississippi. That advantage
is probably offset by the ballot advantage Anderson enjoys by virtue of
being a Democrat in a down-ticket race. This one may come down to how
much TV each can muster.
Presidential
Visits
President
George W. Bush
President
George W. Bush visited the Magnolia State in November, where he helped
his friend Haley Barbour raise over $2 million for Barbour’s campaign
coffers. Bush reportedly will make to return visits to Mississippi on
Saturday, November 1st. This time, instead of helping raise money, Bush
will help Barbour energize Republicans and maybe even sway a few voters
who are still undecided.
According
to sources close to the Barbour campaign, Bush will make a Saturday morning
stop in the Republican stronghold of DeSoto County to rally voters for
Barbour. After two stops in Kentucky, the President might return to Mississippi
for some last minute campaigning on the Gulf Coast.
Last
year, Bush very effectively campaigned across the country to help the
GOP win several contested Senate contests. Republican candidates in Georgia,
Missouri, Minnesota, Tennessee and Texas and South Carolina received major
boosts from Bush’s barnstorming.
In
a governor’s race as close as this one appears to be, Bush’s
visits could be decisive for Barbour.
Vice
President Dick Cheney
According
to published reports, Columbus Mayor Jeffrey Rupp confirms that the Secret
Service has been in Columbus scouting locations for an appearance by Vice
President Dick Cheney. Cheney will rally Barbour’s troops in Columbus
on the afternoon of Monday, October 27th. As a former Secretary of Defense,
Cheney will attract plenty of interest in Columbus – a town heavily
intertwined with the nearby Columbus Air Force Base.
Bob
Dole
Former
Senate Majority Leader and 1996 GOP Presidential nominee Bob Dole is making
two stops in Mississippi for Barbour later this week. Dole will headline
a Salute to Veterans event in Jackson and Biloxi this Friday. Dole, who
stills bears scars from his service in World War II, will than make his
way to Jackson for a 2:00 p.m. rally at the Ag Museum on Lakeland Drive.
Rudy
Giuliani
Former
New York Mayor Rudy Giuliani is visiting Pascagoula on behalf of Barbour
on Wednesday, October 29th.
Dems
A
year after the ’99 elections, Musgrove felt comfortable enough to
host Vice President Al Gore in Mississippi and even endorsed him in his
bid against George W. Bush for the presidency. In an election year, it’s
a different story. Musgrove and other statewide Democrats are keeping
their national Democrat counterparts at arms length.
However,
statewide Democrats are banning together to rally their base in events
around the state. Last weekend, several hundred of their supporters turned-out
for a get-out-the-vote rally in Pontotoc that was attended by Musgrove,
Blackmon and Gary Anderson. The Dems moved their show up the road to New
Albany later in the day with a reportedly much smaller crowd on hand.
New Websites
www.ronniemustgo.com
– The Mississippi Republican Party launched ronniemustgo.com last
week as a take off of a Jim Carey movie poster from the movie “Liar
Liar” about a lawyer who couldn’t tell the truth. According
to the state GOP the site features some of Musgrove’s more outrageous
claims. The day the site was launched a pop-up of the movie poster “True
Lies” was featured as the next edition of the site but the party
took it down at Chairman Jim Herring’s request.
www.barbarablackmon.com
– An enterprising Mississippi College student is responsible for
barbarablackmon.com which details some of Lt. Governor candidate Barbara
Blackmon’s most controversial votes as a state senator.
www.mississippiwatchdog.com
– Treasurer candidate Tate Reeves unveiled mississippiwatchdog.com
this week laying out his watchdog plan for Mississippi taxpayers.
Judge
Pickering
Click
here to watch
Congressman
Chip Pickering faced incumbent Congressman Ronnie Shows in his re-election
bid last year, but he may be facing a tougher campaign this year (Pickering
ended up cruising to victory against Shows, getting 65 percent of the
vote) in his efforts to secure Senate confirmation for his father.
Judge
Charles Pickering was nominated by President Bush to a seat on the Fifth
Circuit Court of Appeals. Senate Democrats have stalled the nomination
for over a year. Pickering was recently approved by the Senate Judiciary
Committee, but he faces a filibuster in the Senate. Needing only one or
three votes to break the filibuster (60 votes are needed for cloture to
end a filibuster), Congressman Pickering has been vigorously working the
Senate to sway the handful of votes needed for his dad to win confirmation.
Pickering
supporters have gone on a PR offensive to secure the nomination for the
Mississippi Judge. They recently released this video http://committeeforjustice.org/contents/commercial/index.shtml
in support of the Judge’s nomination.
Debates
Gubernatorial
debates concluded this week with a debate WLOX-TV in Biloxi. For the most
part, both candidates stuck to their scripts in all four gubernatorial
debates. The liveliest debate was in Cleveland on the campus of Delta
State University. The debate was par for the course for the first 55 minutes
until each candidate got a chance for his closing comments.
In
his close, Barbour challenged Musgrove to defend spot the governor has
on TV accusing Barbour of poisoning children. Some reports say Barbour
lost his cool. Others conclude Musgrove “wimped out” when
he failed to defend his ad or even look at his opponent as Barbour challenged
him to look him in the eyes while accusing him of poisoning children.
Supertalk MS
Expanding
The SuperTalk Mississippi Network has announced another new station to
its talk network. Tentative airdate for WKBB-FM in West Point is November
1st. The station will begin immediate upgrades to 25,000 watts and will
be serving the West Point, Columbus, Starkville markets.
Simulcast
coverage area now includes
WFMN-FM 97.3 Jackson and Central MS area
WFMM-FM 97.3 Hattiesburg and the Pine Belt area
WTCD-FM 96.9 Greenwood, the Delta
WTNM-FM 105.5 Oxford, Batesville, Water Valley
WXRZ-FM 94.3 Corinth, Booneville, Iuka, Ripley
and coming Nov. 1st WKBB-FM 105.5 West Point, Columbus, Starkville.
MR Polling
Which regional state newspaper do you trust the most?
Biloxi Sun Herald – 40.33%
Memphis Commercial Appeal – 22.07%
Tupelo Daily Journal – 19.63%
Jackson Clarion Ledger – 17.96%
Who
has the best campaign ads?
Haley Barbour – 31.96%
Scott Newton – 28.01%
Ronnie Musgrove – 17.13%
Amy Tuck – 7.41%
Jim Hood – 7.25%
Tate Reeves – 4.78%
Barbara Blackmon – 3.46%
Picture
of the Week
|